Monday, September 06, 2010

WHO WILL GO ?

As we prepare for the 2011 World Cup.Who will be sacked Peter De Villiers or John Smidt?
Or do we have to sack either of them.Is it necessary.Also how good was PDV as opposed to Mallet and White and coaches before him?

19 comments:

  1. PDV should shut his mouth.Thats what gets him into shite always

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sho'ayb Peer via facebook. He rode on jake whites coat tails, he was just a token. White prep the team, he had the team fine tuned, a few changes to the team and PdV could not answer. We knew NZ and AUS were preparing for WCup and would be diff from last year, SA needs a change, PdV should go.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Faheem Patel via fb. Agree with Peer,Pvd is rubbish!Bring Jake back!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Zayd Ebrahim via fb. since 2001 jake nurtured many of these players! Essentially it's his players so it should be his team as well. He knows how to get the best out of players. Along with Smit they'd be a fantastic force once again!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Mohammed Akhalwaya via fb.
    Sack them both

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ahmed Pahad via fb- Dont judge the team now and dont go interferring with a winning team. This tri nations and the next is about working out who the best 30 players to goto the world cup are. PDV hasnt played his best 15 in their preferred position once in thi...s tri nations which shows that the boks are in experimental mode currently. There's a few fringe players that need to be developed over the next 12 months, that need some game time with the bok team, PDV is doing that, he already has his first 15 combination he's now preparing his next 15... this team have it in them to goto New Zealand and win the world cup, they've already showed that they CAN win in New Zealand.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ahmed Pahad via fb- PDV also has the highest win ration than any other coach in springbok history ! so on stats, he IS our best coach ever... now do you really want to kick the best out coz he's NOT WHITE ... and bring in someone with a mediocre springbok record ?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Faheem Patel via fb- Why must you bring race in to this?No one said anything about him being NOT WHITE.
    Yesterday at 6:24pm · LikeUnlike · .Faheem Patel And Jake won us a world cup.His by no means 'mediocre'!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ahmed Pahad via fb- Faheem, have you played the game? have you been involved within the structures of SA rugby ? Have you worked with, played with and dealt with Rugby administrators in this country on a personal level ? If you can answer YES to those questions then ur eligible to comment , if not ... well use ur imagination !
    PDV was not the best applicant when the post became available but due to pressure from govt the position was handed to him with alot of strings attached. despite all of this, he's proven everyone wrong including myself that he can do the jo...b. He's had 1 bad tri nations (which you cannot judge him on because he's experimenting looking forward to the world cup - which is the same thing Jake White did, SA were poor in both the 2006 and 2007 tri nations) and suddenly the whole country is calling for his head. The man has continuously proved everyone wrong, he's delivered the results when it mattered, he has a contract up until the world cup.... let him see it through, coz i really dont wanna see Jomo Sono take the bokke to the world cup.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Zayd Ebrahim via fb- it doesn't 't matter what we say PdV's review is only at the end of the month so SARU will make the call!!!
    ‎4 years ago jake white was in a worst position so in the same spirit it would be unfair to sack him now. The players are out of form as well. Just look at how habana has performed!! The grand slam tour will be keenly watched now!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Azee wasn't pdv the only man to have won at the house of pain in new zealand

    ReplyDelete
  12. Zayd Ebrahim via fb-
    nas that's correct. I think its the boks one and only victory there as well

    ReplyDelete
  13. neeb Thokan via fb-
    Hav faith in pdv..reality is rugby needs a black coach.he is the best black coach.back himdont oppose him..aus n nz have phenomenal teams so even if we dont win wc it wont be pdvs fault.

    ReplyDelete
  14. med Pahad via fb-
    We're going to win the world cup ... MARK MY WORDS ! New Zealand are getting up to their old tricks of peaking too soon and their attitude in the tournament is going to be the same as before, the trend is being followed already. Australia is a team in decline, we've shown with experimental teams that we can beat them. Those are the only 2 real threats in the world cup unless we come across France on their 1 day at the world cup where they play the most phenomenal rugby.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Moe Cassim via fb-
    Guys relax give the man a chance... White was just as bad in the 2006. We have more than good enuf players to pull us through the cup. Its a trail period right now. As for smit... Well his record speaks for itself. He is and always will be ...one of the greatest rugby captains everand there is no replacement for experience esp in a world cup. And pahad as far as u go its not about race or anything of that sort...we all love the team and all want the best out of the team all the time so the frustration is understandable

    ReplyDelete
  16. Zaheer Talia via fb-
    White never played amazing rugby at the world cup. All he did do was play rugby. The other teams there were trying to play amazing rugby and that blew up in their face. As for SA rugby, they are just rubbish. The Aussies are naturing a youn...g side and the weekends victory will only spur them on even more for next year. As for NZ well next year they go in search of the holy grail on home soil and you would be mad to assume they going to lose. Old tutus should shut his mouth and rather concentrate on coaching this very ordinary team. They are by no means special. It don't matter who you have coaching them they will still not be lifting the William Webb Ellis next year.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Azhar Moola via fb-
    In pdv we trust!
    Pdv has fielded more players of color which is what I wanted to c. Senior playeqs are not in form and that aint his fault. Smit, bakkies, matfield, habana r playing kak. Fourie du preez injured brusouw injured. Discipline of team not his fault. I want to c him stay but think they wil blast him. He will b the fall guy!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Mohammed Naeem Loonat via fb-
    With a fully fit squad and players in form we will be a force to reckon with. Mistakes on the pitch cost the Boks NOT PDIV. He is not the one giving away penalties & missing tackles. As for Jake, had his chance when he was offered a contract renewal and refused it.. SO PISS OFF JW. Win or loose PDIV is the man.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hey Azee

    Fuck PDV and the BOKS!

    The Lions are in sublime from and i know you care more abouth them then the Boks! John Mitchell to take the Lions to Currie Cup and Super 14 Glory!

    Elton Jantjes - BOK Flyhalf for the Future!

    ReplyDelete

Leave a Comment.Become a Member.Open a Google account Now!